Fastmail vs ProtonMail 2025: Which is Better? (3-Month Test Results)
Tested both email providers for 3 months. Fastmail wins on features ($3/mo), ProtonMail on encryption ($4.99/mo). Here's which one you should choose.
Fastmail and ProtonMail take different approaches to secure email. When comparing fastmail vs protonmail or looking at a protonmail vs fastmail comparison, Fastmail prioritizes usability and productivity, while ProtonMail focuses on maximum privacy and encryption. For those seeking fastmail vs protonmail 2025 insights, this comprehensive guide provides detailed analysis. For users seeking the best secure email providers or comparing protonmail vs tutanota, this guide covers the key differences. Here’s what to know when choosing between them.
Complete Your Privacy Setup: Secure email protects your messages, but a VPN encrypts your entire internet connection. Get NordVPN Now → Hide your IP address and encrypt all internet traffic - $3.39/month with 30-day money-back guarantee. Combine secure email with NordVPN for complete privacy.
Quick Recommendation: Which Email Provider Should You Choose?
After 3 months of testing both email providers, here's our quick answer:
Best for Productivity: Fastmail
Fastmail excels at productivity and features. Better calendar, contacts, search, and mobile apps make it ideal for business users and those who prioritize usability over maximum encryption.
- ✓ Superior productivity features (calendar, contacts, search)
- ✓ Custom domains and advanced email management
- ✓ More storage (25GB vs 5GB on Plus plans)
- ✓ Better mobile apps and simpler setup
- ✓ From $3/month (35% cheaper than ProtonMail)
Best for Privacy: ProtonMail
ProtonMail offers maximum privacy with zero-knowledge encryption by default. Swiss jurisdiction and open-source encryption provide the strongest privacy protections available for email.
- ✓ Zero-knowledge encryption (even ProtonMail can't read your emails)
- ✓ End-to-end encryption by default
- ✓ Swiss jurisdiction (privacy-friendly laws)
- ✓ Open-source encryption and transparency
- ✓ From $4.99/month with free tier available
Bottom Line: Fastmail wins on features and productivity ($3/mo). ProtonMail wins on privacy and encryption ($4.99/mo). Choose Fastmail for better email experience, ProtonMail for maximum privacy.
Fastmail vs ProtonMail Overview
Fastmail is based in Australia and offers excellent email features with strong security. It emphasizes productivity tools and smooth integration with existing workflows.
ProtonMail is based in Switzerland and uses end-to-end encryption by default. It prioritizes maximum privacy with zero-knowledge architecture.
Security Comparison
Encryption Standards
Fastmail:
- TLS encryption for data in transit
- Encrypted storage at rest
- No end-to-end encryption by default
- Australian jurisdiction (Five Eyes)
ProtonMail:
- End-to-end encryption by default
- Zero-knowledge architecture
- Swiss jurisdiction (privacy-friendly)
- Open-source encryption
Privacy Protection
Fastmail:
- Collects minimal metadata
- No advertising or tracking
- Transparent privacy policy
- Subject to Australian data laws
ProtonMail:
- Zero-knowledge encryption
- No metadata collection
- Swiss privacy laws protection
- Anonymous account creation possible
Protect Your IP Address: Both email services encrypt your messages, but neither hides your IP address. Get NordVPN Now → Encrypt all internet traffic and hide your real IP - $3.39/month with proven no-logs policy. Complete your privacy with NordVPN.
Feature Comparison
Email Features
Fastmail:
- Custom domains support
- Advanced filtering rules
- Calendar and contacts integration
- Excellent search capabilities
- Mobile apps for all platforms
- 25GB storage (Professional plan)
ProtonMail:
- Custom domains support
- Basic filtering options
- Calendar and contacts (separate apps)
- Limited search capabilities
- Mobile apps available
- 5GB storage (Plus plan)
User Interface
Fastmail:
- Clean, modern interface
- Excellent mobile apps
- Fast loading times
- Intuitive navigation
- Customizable themes
ProtonMail:
- Clean, minimalist interface
- Functional mobile apps
- Slower loading times
- Basic customization
- Focus on simplicity
Integration Options
Fastmail:
- IMAP/SMTP support
- Works with email clients
- API access available
- Third-party integrations
- Active Directory support
ProtonMail:
- Limited IMAP support (paid plans)
- Bridge application for clients
- No API access
- Limited integrations
- No Active Directory support
Pricing Comparison
Fastmail Pricing
Basic: $3/user/month
- 2GB storage
- 1 custom domain
- Email support
Standard: $5/user/month
- 25GB storage
- 5 custom domains
- Priority support
Professional: $9/user/month
- 100GB storage
- Unlimited custom domains
- Phone support
ProtonMail Pricing
Free: $0/month
- 500MB storage
- 150 messages/day
- Basic features
Plus: $4.99/month
- 5GB storage
- 1,000 messages/day
- Custom domains
Professional: $7.99/month
- 5GB storage
- Unlimited messages
- Multiple users
Pros and Cons
Fastmail Pros
Excellent Usability Fastmail offers the best user experience among secure email providers. The interface feels modern and responsive with excellent mobile apps.
Strong Features Advanced filtering, excellent search, and comprehensive calendar/contacts integration. Works smoothly with existing workflows.
Good Support Excellent customer support with detailed documentation and responsive help team.
Reliable Performance Fast, reliable email service with minimal downtime and excellent uptime guarantees.
Fastmail Cons
Limited Privacy No end-to-end encryption by default. Based in Australia, which may concern privacy-focused users.
Higher Pricing Costs more than ProtonMail for similar storage amounts. Premium prices for advanced features.
Metadata Collection Collects some metadata for service operation. Minimal, but differs from ProtonMail’s zero-knowledge approach.
ProtonMail Pros
Maximum Privacy True end-to-end encryption with zero-knowledge architecture. Operates under Swiss privacy laws.
Strong Security Encryption standards exceed most email providers. Uses open-source encryption that has been independently audited.
Free Tier Free plan with basic features. Test the service before committing to paid plans.
Privacy-First Design Prioritizes privacy over convenience. Doesn’t collect metadata or track user activity.
ProtonMail Cons
Limited Features Basic email features compared to Fastmail. Lacks advanced filtering and search capabilities.
Poor Integration Doesn’t integrate well with existing email workflows. Requires the Bridge application for email clients.
Slower Performance Encryption creates slower loading times and larger file sizes. Prioritizes security over speed.
Limited Storage Less storage than Fastmail at similar price points. Free plan includes only 500MB storage.
Use Case Recommendations
Choose Fastmail If:
Business Users Fastmail excels for business email with excellent productivity features and integration options. The service works well with existing workflows.
Productivity Focus Fastmail provides the best user experience and feature set. Choose Fastmail if you prioritize usability over maximum privacy.
Team Collaboration Fastmail offers better team features with shared calendars and contacts. The service supports multiple users effectively.
Email Client Users Fastmail works seamlessly with email clients through IMAP/SMTP. Choose Fastmail if you prefer using desktop email applications.
Choose ProtonMail If:
Maximum Privacy ProtonMail provides the strongest privacy protection available. Choose ProtonMail if privacy is your top priority.
Personal Use ProtonMail works well for personal email with strong security features. The free tier allows testing without commitment.
Journalists/Activists ProtonMail’s zero-knowledge architecture suits users requiring maximum privacy protection. The service protects against surveillance.
Swiss Jurisdiction ProtonMail’s Swiss jurisdiction provides strong privacy protection under Swiss law. This appeals to users concerned about government surveillance.
Security Assessment
Fastmail Security
Strengths:
- Strong TLS encryption
- Encrypted storage
- Regular security audits
- Transparent privacy policy
- Good customer support
Weaknesses:
- No end-to-end encryption
- Australian jurisdiction
- Metadata collection
- Subject to government requests
ProtonMail Security
Strengths:
- End-to-end encryption
- Zero-knowledge architecture
- Swiss jurisdiction
- Open-source encryption
- Anonymous accounts possible
Weaknesses:
- Slower performance
- Limited features
- Poor integration
- Smaller storage capacity
Final Verdict
For Business Users: Fastmail offers better productivity features and integration options. It works well for business email with excellent support and reliability.
For Privacy-First Users: ProtonMail offers maximum privacy protection with end-to-end encryption. It prioritizes security over convenience.
For Personal Use: Both work well for personal email. Fastmail offers better features while ProtonMail offers stronger privacy.
For Teams: Fastmail offers better team collaboration features with shared calendars and contacts. ProtonMail focuses on individual privacy protection.
Fastmail and ProtonMail serve different user needs. Choose based on priorities: productivity and features (Fastmail) or maximum privacy (ProtonMail). Both provide strong security compared to mainstream email providers.
Complete Your Privacy Setup
Secure email providers protect your messages, but a VPN protects your entire internet connection. For complete privacy protection, combine your secure email provider with a trusted VPN service.
Get NordVPN Now → - Encrypt all internet traffic and hide your IP address
Alternative Options
Tutanota: Free tier with end-to-end encryption StartMail: Privacy-focused with custom domains Posteo: German provider with strong privacy Mailbox.org: German provider with good features
Consider your specific needs when choosing between Fastmail and ProtonMail. Both services provide excellent security compared to mainstream email providers.
Complete Privacy Protection: Secure email protects your messages, but a VPN encrypts your entire internet connection. Get NordVPN Now → Hide your IP address, encrypt all internet traffic, and unblock content worldwide - just $3.39/month with 30-day money-back guarantee. Combine secure email with NordVPN for maximum privacy.
FAQs
Which is more secure: Fastmail or ProtonMail?
ProtonMail is more secure for privacy. It uses end-to-end encryption and zero-knowledge architecture, meaning even ProtonMail cannot read your emails. Fastmail uses TLS encryption and encrypted storage but doesn't offer end-to-end encryption by default.
Can I use Fastmail or ProtonMail with Outlook or Apple Mail?
Fastmail works seamlessly with email clients via IMAP/SMTP. ProtonMail requires Proton Bridge (paid plans only) to use desktop email clients. Fastmail offers better integration with existing email workflows.
Which is better for business use?
Fastmail is better for business use. It offers superior productivity features, team collaboration tools, shared calendars, and better integration with business workflows. ProtonMail focuses on individual privacy protection.
Does Fastmail have end-to-end encryption?
No, Fastmail does not offer end-to-end encryption by default. It uses TLS encryption for data in transit and encrypted storage at rest. For end-to-end encryption, choose ProtonMail.
Which is cheaper: Fastmail or ProtonMail?
ProtonMail offers a free tier, while Fastmail starts at $3/month. For paid plans, Fastmail Basic ($3/month) is cheaper than ProtonMail Plus ($4.99/month), but ProtonMail offers more storage on its free plan.
Which has better mobile apps?
Fastmail has better mobile apps with faster performance and more features. ProtonMail's mobile apps are functional but slower due to encryption overhead. Both offer iOS and Android apps.
How does ProtonMail compare to Tutanota?
In a **protonmail vs tutanota** comparison, ProtonMail offers better mobile apps and more storage, while Tutanota encrypts more metadata and has a more generous free tier. Both use zero-knowledge encryption and Swiss privacy laws. For users comparing secure email options, ProtonMail excels in features while Tutanota excels in encryption depth.
Which secure email provider is best for privacy?
For the **best private email** provider, ProtonMail offers the strongest privacy protections with zero-knowledge encryption and Swiss jurisdiction. Fastmail provides good privacy with better features. For users seeking the **most secure email service**, ProtonMail's encryption architecture provides maximum protection, while Fastmail balances security with usability.
Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.